Language: Italiano  Help: FAQ and info    
Benvenuto su U2start.com!
Crea un account gratuito qui o connettiti qui.
 info sul forum
 statistiche
 segnalibri
 sottoscrizioni
 segna tutti i topic come letti
 cerca nei forum
 topic attivi
 topic in cui hai postato

Different Live Versions of LIB and BTBS

Questo topic è stato iniziato il 2008-09-12 12:59 pm.
Ci sono 31 messaggi in questo topic.
    Ritorna alla lista dei topic
  Apri un nuovo topic in questo forum
  Scrivi un post in questo topic


  Riporta questo topic a un membro dello staff
     Forum » U2 Live
«  indietro   1  2  3    avanti  »
Apri un nuovo topic   |   Scrivi un post    
postato da dieder (Member) il 2008-09-12 07:55 pm cita

Originariamente postato da MWSAH:
Speaking of BTBS, the one from Rotterdam'92 is slightly different too, and extended. Just great..


great version but I donīt like the sound of Bono that song. With that voice transformer or so.

postato da djrlewis (Crew member) il 2008-09-13 12:46 am cita

The definitive versions of these 2 songs, in my opinion,are on the Stay single.

For Elevation Bullet, either the Boston version for the Mark Chapman version or a post 9/11 NY show

postato da WojBhoy (Member) il 2008-09-13 12:50 am cita

Originariamente postato da djrlewis:
The definitive versions of these 2 songs, in my opinion,are on the Stay single.

For Elevation Bullet, either the Boston version for the Mark Chapman version or a post 9/11 NY show

Erm...Mark Chapman?

I agree that the Dublin BTBS from the Stay single IS good, but I'd still say the versions from Paris or Dortmund '92 beat it. That said, I'm biased lol.

postato da easports43 (Crew member) il 2008-09-13 12:52 am cita

Originariamente postato da WojBhoy:
[..]
Erm...Mark Chapman?


I was wondering the same lol...

Originariamente postato da WojBhoy:

I agree that the Dublin BTBS from the Stay single IS good, but I'd still say the versions from Paris or Dortmund '92 beat it. That said, I'm biased lol.


Paris, OK, yes I agree that beats Dublin. But Dortmund? Not so sure about that one...

postato da djrlewis (Crew member) il 2008-09-13 12:56 am cita

"Pull the trigger, rock 'n' roll n********"
"What's my name?....Mark Chapman"

Go watch Boston at once.

(He's the guy who shot John Lennon)

Yet to listen to Paris '92.......

postato da WojBhoy (Member) il 2008-09-13 12:57 am cita

Originariamente postato da easports43:
I was wondering the same lol...

[..]

Paris, OK, yes I agree that beats Dublin. But Dortmund? Not so sure about that one..

The solo dear boy, the solo. I mean, the song itself is performed pretty damned well, but Edge pulls off one hell of a solo (and this is going by ZooTV standards). It was my favourite BTBS until I got hold of the Paris gig...

Originariamente postato da djrlewis:
"Pull the trigger, rock 'n' roll n********"
"What's my name?....Mark Chapman"

Go watch Boston at once.

(He's the guy who shot John Lennon)
Yet to listen to Paris '92.......

Ahhhhhhh...I never realised that's what he said lol, I always thought he said something like "John shot me!" etc.

As they always say, you learn something new everyday (I knew Mark Chapman was the guy who shot Lennon, but I just wasn't aware that's what Bono says lol...)

postato da easports43 (Crew member) il 2008-09-13 01:00 am cita

Originariamente postato da djrlewis:
"Pull the trigger, rock 'n' roll n********"
"What's my name?....Mark Chapman"

Go watch Boston at once.

(He's the guy who shot John Lennon)

Yet to listen to Paris '92.......


Ah, OK. Now I've got it...

postato da easports43 (Crew member) il 2008-09-13 01:01 am cita

Originariamente postato da WojBhoy:
[..]
The solo dear boy, the solo. I mean, the song itself is performed pretty damned well, but Edge pulls off one hell of a solo (and this is going by ZooTV standards). It was my favourite BTBS until I got hold of the Paris gig...



OK, if we're basing it purely on the solo, I'm forced to agree. But overall performance-wise, it's certainly not the "best". All about personal preference though...

postato da WojBhoy (Member) il 2008-09-13 01:07 am cita

Originariamente postato da easports43:
OK, if we're basing it purely on the solo, I'm forced to agree. But overall performance-wise, it's certainly not the "best". All about personal preference though...

Well, for me, a lot of post-JT BTBSs are about the solo, but that's the guitar player in me getting the better of common sense lol. I have to say, the Wembley shows do rock my socks, with Bono's rants and what have you. A lot of it is also about the guitar part vs. Bono's vocals, hence why I'm not too keen on a lot of Elevation and Vertigo versions - just palm muting Wah-Wah as opposed to the little riffs that Edge played during ZooTV and PopMart renditions, I think there's only one winner.

That said, I watched Slane again today, that is a good performance as is the Boston DVD, but they're nothing more than good in my opinion. JT and LT, they were sticking with the album format, but if you're gonna develop the song into a bit more of a gritty live entity, it needs a bit more than an alternative solo in my view...

postato da easports43 (Crew member) il 2008-09-13 01:12 am cita

Originariamente postato da WojBhoy:
[..]
Well, for me, a lot of post-JT BTBSs are about the solo, but that's the guitar player in me getting the better of common sense lol. I have to say, the Wembley shows do rock my socks, with Bono's rants and what have you. A lot of it is also about the guitar part vs. Bono's vocals, hence why I'm not too keen on a lot of Elevation and Vertigo versions - just palm muting Wah-Wah as opposed to the little riffs that Edge played during ZooTV and PopMart renditions, I think there's only one winner.

That said, I watched Slane again today, that is a good performance as is the Boston DVD, but they're nothing more than good in my opinion. JT and LT, they were sticking with the album format, but if you're gonna develop the song into a bit more of a gritty live entity, it needs a bit more than an alternative solo in my view...


haha. What's funny is that I've always hated the palm muting wah-wah bit. It's almost as if Edge felt he couldn't top ZOO/Popmart....

I will say I'm not a huge fan of the JT or LT versions....although the Star Spangled Banner was cool. R & H is really the only pre-zoo version I like other than the album version of course.

postato da djrlewis (Crew member) il 2008-09-13 01:14 am cita

Thus ends Harry's thesis on BTBS ......

Can you do that for every song?

postato da easports43 (Crew member) il 2008-09-13 01:19 am cita

Originariamente postato da djrlewis:
Thus ends Harry's thesis on BTBS ......

Can you do that for every song?


Maybe we need a song review option for him

     Forum » U2 Live
«  indietro   1  2  3    avanti  »
Apri un nuovo topic   |   Scrivi un post    

 


Previous
  • foto alta risoluzione
    Abbiamo 696 foto in alta risoluzione sugli U2 disponibili per te, la collezione di foto più vasta che c'é. La foto aggiunta più di recente é 'October'.
  • canzoni popolari
    La canzone Where The Streets Have No Name é la più richiesta nelle nostre pagine di canzoni e perciò abbastanza popolare, in base alle canzoni scelte come preferite dai nostri utenti Bad é la canzone preferita di tutti i tempi.
  • u2news
    Trattiamo le news di molti siti Web internazionali sugli U2 incluso U2.com, la notizia più popolare nelle scorse due settimane é stata 'U2 rocking O2 Arena ... as the support act' da atu2.com.
  • fan del mese
    Ogni mese focalizziamo l'attenzione su un fan, il fan di questo mese é l'utente drewhiggins. Ciascun fan del mese ci regala un'intervista, puoi leggere l'intervista con drewhiggins qui.
  • performance live rilevanti
    Secondo l'utente markp91 la canzone Stuck In A Moment You Can't Get Out Of dall'album All That You Can't Leave Behind é stata suonata in modo eccellente il 2001-07-31 a Arnhem, Netherlands.
  • concerti popolari
    Secondo le recensioni dei nostri utenti, 1987-07-08 - Brussels, Belgium é il miglior bootleg della nostra collezione. I nostri utenti inoltre ritengono che 1993-08-28 - Dublin, Ireland fu un grande concerto poiché é stato inserito molte volte tra i bootleg preferiti.
  • lo sapevi?
    Adam Clayton did send some fake mail to his fellow bandmates in the early days of U2 in 1977, Adam was U2's PR man in that time.
  • statistiche
    Attualmente ci sono 4,745 topic aperti sul forum con più di 208,073 messaggi. Più di 13,250 fans sono membri di U2start. L'età media degli utenti di U2start è 29 tenendo conto solo degli utenti che hanno condiviso la loro data di nascita .
  • audio e video bootleg
    Su U2start sono disponibili le più grandi collezioni di bootleg audio e video, l'audio bootleg aggiunto più di recente é 2005-09-17 - Toronto, Ontario mentre l'ultimo video bootleg é Live from Honolulu, Hawaii (720p HD 3-cam, matrix sound).
  • nuovi fan tra noi
    Il fan che si é registrato più di recente a U2start é cosecosi, benvenuto a U2start cosecosi! Poiché sei un nuovo utente sarebbe bello se ti presentassi a noi nel forum Welcome to U2start y'all.
  • recenti news del sito
    Jeremy, known as haytrain here, is the latest addition to the U2start crew. Jeremy will be a crew member specialised in bootlegs, he will mainly work on maintaining our bootleg collection, making it even better, more r.. (leggi di più)
  • bootleg del mese
    Ogni mese focalizziamo l'attenzione su un bootleg, quello di questo mese é del 1989-12-27 a Dublin, Ireland. Puoi scaricare questo bootleg, leggere le recensioni o scriverne una tu qui. Puoi anche partecipare alla discussione su questo bootleg nei nostri forum.
Next


 
"How did I de-Zoo myself? I turned my television off. It was simple. My white dot has receded out of view. There was nothing left. The transmission had well and truly run its course." - The Edge
 
Make a donation © U2start.com v3.0 (2006-2008) RSS feeds
U2start è un prodotto di successo di Remy.tv dall'Olanda.U2start non è associato agli U2, alla loro etichetta di registrazione o ad altre società affiliate. Il copyright sui contenuti appartiene ai rispettivi proprietari.